Skip to content
Deputy Chief Minister

Sniawbhalang Dhar

National People's Party

Deputy Chief Minister of Meghalaya

Performance

Official record

As a minister, they don't ask questions or table private bills by convention, so a performance percentile isn't shown.

How well they do their official job — attendance, questions, funds. From government records.

How is this worked out?

Public rating

People's opinion

No ratings yet

How would you rate this leader?

PoorGreat

One rating per person. You can change it later. · Ratings are people's opinion, shown separately from official facts.

How people ratedConfidence: No ratings yet

No ratings yet

About

Sniawbhalang Dhar is the Deputy Chief Minister of Meghalaya (National People's Party).

Role in the Meghalaya Government

As Deputy Chief Minister, this leader runs these departments:

  • Commerce & Industries

  • Prisons & Correctional Services

  • Transport

  • Urban Affairs

What they are accountable for

This person holds more than one office. Here is what they are accountable for in each role.

Deputy Chief Minister (State / UT)

A senior minister in a state (or Union Territory) government given the extra title "Deputy CM" — but with the same legal powers as any other minister there.

You can hold them accountable for

  • Showing up for and taking part in Cabinet meetings and the elected assembly (Vidhan Sabha, or the UT assembly)
  • Running the departments (portfolios) they are given honestly and well, and delivering on the promises made for those departments
  • Answering questions and debates in the House about the departments they hold
  • Spending their departments' public money and schemes carefully — no waste, leakage or corruption
  • Being transparent — declaring assets, liabilities and any criminal cases in their election affidavit, and disclosing conflicts of interest
  • Following the Constitution, the law and the rules of the House, and keeping their oath of office and secrecy (Article 164)
  • Sharing collective responsibility for the decisions of the whole Council of Ministers (standing by the government's joint decisions)
  • Making sure their departments answer people's grievances and Right to Information (RTI) requests
  • Ethical, corruption-free conduct and obeying the anti-defection rules and any code of conduct for ministers
  • Being reachable and responsive to citizens, especially in their own constituency
  • Representing and serving their own constituency as an elected MLA or MLC
  • Explaining and defending their departments' policies and budgets to the public and the House
  • Not misusing the high-profile 'Deputy CM' title, its ceremonial rank, or government resources for personal or party gain
What this role covers — and what it does not

What they do

  • Running the specific state departments/portfolios assigned to them (varies by person and state — e.g. Finance, Home, Health, Public Works, Urban Development)
  • Taking government decisions as a member of the Council of Ministers (Cabinet)
  • Piloting bills, the budget and policies for their departments in the legislature
  • Answering questions, motions and debates in the Assembly about their departments
  • Overseeing the schemes, spending and officials of the departments they hold
  • Taking a higher ceremonial/protocol rank at official state events because of the 'deputy' designation (protocol only, not extra power)
  • Serving their own constituents as an elected MLA (or MLC)

Not their job — ask instead

  • National subjects like defence, railways, income tax, foreign affairs and passports — these belong to the central government and your MP
  • Departments the Deputy CM does not hold — ask the minister who actually holds that portfolio, or the Chief Minister
  • Final authority over the whole government or over other ministers — that rests with the Chief Minister; 'deputy' gives no power to command colleagues
  • Everyday local works like garbage, street lights, local roads, local water and drains — your Municipality or Panchayat
  • Automatically becoming acting Chief Minister when the CM is away or resigns — there is no automatic succession; the ruling party's legislators and the Governor (or Lieutenant Governor in a UT) decide
  • Court cases and judgments — these are decided by the judiciary, not by any minister

Sources: Constitution of India, Article 164 — appointment of the Chief Minister and other ministers by the Governor, collective responsibility to the Legislative Assembly, and the ministerial oath of office and secrecy (India Code / legislative.gov.in) · Supreme Court of India, 12 February 2024 — dismissal of the PIL challenging the appointment of Deputy Chief Ministers; the Court held that a Deputy CM is a minister like any other, the title is 'only a label' with no extra constitutional status and no higher salary, and does not breach the rule that a CM must be a member of the legislature · President's Secretariat / Ministry of Home Affairs, Table (Warrant) of Precedence — used only for ceremonial and protocol occasions, with no bearing on legal powers or day-to-day government; within their own State a Deputy Chief Minister is placed above ordinary State Cabinet Ministers, showing the title carries ceremonial precedence but not extra constitutional power (mha.gov.in) · Constitution of India, Article 239AA (National Capital Territory of Delhi) and the Government of Union Territories Act, 1963 (Puducherry) — the basis for a Council of Ministers, and hence any Deputy CM, in Union Territories that have a legislature, where the Lieutenant Governor acts in the Governor's place (India Code) · PRS Legislative Research — functioning of State Legislatures and Councils of Ministers (prsindia.org)

Member of Legislative Assembly (MLA)

An MLA is the person your area elects to your state's law-making house (the Vidhan Sabha) to help make state laws, approve the state budget, and raise your local problems with the government.

You can hold them accountable for

  • Attending Assembly sessions regularly and taking an active part — speaking in debates, asking questions, and voting on bills and motions (poor attendance and silence are legitimate things to question).
  • Making and improving laws: reading bills carefully, debating them, proposing amendments, and voting on them in the Vidhan Sabha — on State List and Concurrent List subjects, from health, land and water to school education.
  • Guarding public money — scrutinising and voting on the state budget, taxes, and money bills (Articles 202-207), and checking that spending gives value.
  • Holding the state government to account: using Question Hour, calling-attention and adjournment motions, resolutions, and committee work (e.g. Public Accounts, Estimates committees).
  • Representing everyone in the constituency — including people who did not vote for them — being reachable, holding constituency office hours, and raising local grievances with ministers and officials.
  • Using the MLA Local Area Development (MLA-LAD) fund honestly and only recommending genuinely needed public works (where the scheme exists; amounts and rules vary by state, and in a few states it is not run).
  • Disclosing assets, liabilities, and educational/criminal details in the election affidavit to the Election Commission, and declaring conflicts of interest as required by House rules.
  • Following the law and the rules and conduct of the House — respecting the Speaker's authority, maintaining decorum, and not disrupting proceedings.
  • Not defecting: obeying the Tenth Schedule (anti-defection law) rules on party loyalty, and accepting disqualification consequences if breached.
  • Ethical conduct — no bribery, no cash-for-questions or cash-for-votes, no misuse of office, no intimidation, and declaring interests before speaking or voting on matters they benefit from.
  • Helping constituents access their rights and government schemes (pensions, ration cards, housing, scholarships, etc.) and following up their grievances with the administration.
  • Being transparent and answerable about their own record — attendance, questions asked, fund utilisation, and work done for the area.
  • If serving as a Minister or Chief Minister: running that department or the government well, delivering on its mandate, and answering to the House for it (this is an extra duty, not one every MLA has).
What this role covers — and what it does not

What they do

  • Debating and voting on state bills and laws in the Legislative Assembly, and proposing amendments.
  • The subjects a state can legislate on — the State List and the shared Concurrent List — e.g. police and public order, prisons, public health and hospitals, school education, agriculture and land, water, local government, and roads and buildings, plus state taxes (on Concurrent subjects like education, a central law wins if the two clash).
  • Passing the state budget and approving how the state taxes and spends public money (money bills start in the Assembly).
  • Deciding who governs the state — the Assembly's majority decides who becomes Chief Minister (the Governor formally appoints whoever can hold the Assembly's confidence), and MLAs can move, or must face, confidence and no-confidence motions.
  • Recommending local development works through the MLA-LAD constituency fund, where the state runs one (the MLA recommends; district officials execute).
  • Parliamentary tools to question the executive: Question Hour, calling-attention motions, adjournment/short-duration debates, resolutions, and private member's bills.
  • Membership and scrutiny work on Assembly committees such as Public Accounts, Estimates, and subject committees.
  • Raising constituency grievances and demands directly with ministers, the district administration, and departments.
  • Acting as part of electoral colleges: elected MLAs help elect the President of India (Article 54) and elect the state's Rajya Sabha members (Article 80); in states with a second house they also elect some Legislative Council members.
  • Helping decide some changes to the Constitution — for certain amendments that affect the states' powers, the state Assembly must approve (ratify) them (Article 368).
  • In states that have two houses, taking part in how the Assembly and the Legislative Council work together on laws — though the Assembly has the final say (Article 197).
  • If appointed a Minister/CM: exercising executive powers over the assigned department(s) and the state administration.

Not their job — ask instead

  • National / Union subjects — defence, foreign affairs, railways, national highways, income tax, currency, telecom, and citizenship. Ask your Member of Parliament (MP) and the Union government; these are decided in Parliament, not the state Assembly.
  • Everyday city/village civic services — garbage collection, street lights, local drains, ward roads, and property tax within a municipal or panchayat area. These belong to your Municipal Corporator/Councillor or Panchayat member and the Mayor/Sarpanch and the local body, not the MLA.
  • Actually executing works and running government offices — an ordinary MLA only recommends and demands. Delivery is done by the bureaucracy: the District Collector/Magistrate (called Deputy Commissioner in some states) and department officers, answerable through the government, not directly to the MLA.
  • Court cases, verdicts, bail, and interpreting the law — that is the judiciary (courts), which is independent of legislators.
  • Petrol/diesel pump prices, GST rates, and bank interest rates are not set by one MLA. Fuel prices mostly follow global crude-oil costs plus central excise duty and state VAT; GST rates are fixed jointly by the Union and all the states together in the GST Council; interest rates are set by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). Your state government does set its own VAT on fuel, but that is a government and budget decision, not something a single MLA controls.
  • Giving someone a government job or transferring an official — recruitment is done by public service commissions and recruitment boards on merit; postings are administrative decisions, and pressuring for them can itself be misconduct.
  • Ground-level policing and law-and-order enforcement decisions — handled by the police and the state Home department (an MLA can raise concerns but does not command the police unless serving as the relevant minister).

Sources: Constitution of India, Part VI, Articles 168-212 (State Legislatures), especially Art. 170 (composition of Assemblies), Art. 172 (five-year term), Art. 173 (qualifications), Art. 188 (oath), Arts. 190-191 (vacation of seats and disqualifications), Art. 194 (powers and privileges), Art. 197 (Assembly's final say over the Legislative Council), and Arts. 202-207 (state budget and money bills); plus the Seventh Schedule (division of subjects into Union, State and Concurrent Lists) and Article 368 (state ratification of some constitutional amendments) — https://legislative.gov.in/constitution-of-india/ · Tenth Schedule of the Constitution (Anti-Defection Law) — https://legislative.gov.in/constitution-of-india/ · PRS Legislative Research — explainers on state legislatures and the anti-defection law — https://prsindia.org/ · MLA Local Area Development (MLA-LAD) scheme overview (state-run constituency development funds; rules and amounts vary by state) — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Member_of_Legislative_Assembly_Local_Area_Development_Fund and respective state planning department portals · Election Commission of India — candidate affidavits (assets, liabilities, criminal and educational details) — https://www.eci.gov.in/ and https://affidavit.eci.gov.in/

Who does what?

Their record

A detailed record for this leader is being added.

Are you this leader, or spotted a mistake?

We publish only sourced facts and offer a right to reply. Tell us and we will check.

Request a correction